Mettler Agency would be nothing without our talented, friendly people. A listing of our staff, their history, and contact information is below. We would love it if you'd say hello!

• 

  Thomas Mettler

  President/Principal Agent

  Email: tmettler@mettleragency.com

  Tom Mettler earned his Indiana insurance agent license in 1989 while studying at Ball State University. He graduated in 1991 with a…View more

• 

  David F. Mettler

  Vice-President/Principal Agent

  Email: dmettler@mettleragency.com

  Dave Mettler became licensed to sell insurance in college, where he graduated with a Associate of Science in Business Administration at Vincennes University…View more

• 

  Shelley McCutcheon

  Agent

  Email: smccutcheon@mettleragency.com

  Shelley McCutcheon has been an insurance agent since 1997 and has been at Mettler Agency since 2001. She enjoys her work and finds every day to be a new challenge…View more

• 

  Paul Adkins

  Agent

  Email: padkins@mettleragency.com

  Paul Adkins has been an insurance agent since 2004, and at Mettler Agency since 2005, having graduated from Huntington University in 2003 with an A.S. in Business…View more

• 

  Brandi Shockney

  Agent

  Email: bshockney@mettleragency.com

  Brandi Shockney is an agent for Mettler Insurance, quoting new business and maintaining client policies. She joined Mettler Agency in 2006 and is a…View more

• 

  Debbie Sutton

  Claims and Office Manager

  Email: dsutton@mettleragency.com

  Debbie Sutton is the office manager and senior customer service manager at Mettler Agency, where she’s been since 2002. With more than 20 years in the…View more

• 

  Megan Alberts

  Customer Service Agent

  Email: malberts@mettleragency.com

  Megan Alberts is a customer service agent for Mettler Agency. She joined Mettler Agency in 2011, and became licensed in November of that year. She currently…View more